Table of Contents
Cherry Margarita Recipe That Sings with Summer Flavor
Why Cherry Margaritas Sing for Me
I’m Alex Morgan, and I swear cherries have always had a bit of music in them. One summer afternoon in Lima, I remember Grandma Rosa holding up a paper bag of crimson fruit and saying, “These are ready—they’re humming.” We weren’t baking pies—we were stirring cherry syrup into lime juice and tequila while the air buzzed with salsa from the radio. That was my first cherry margarita memory, even if I didn’t taste one until years later.
Fast-forward to a sweaty July night in Sacramento. I had limes, silver tequila, and a bowl of sweet Bing cherries that wouldn’t stop staring at me. I halved them, muddled them into my shaker, and added a splash of triple sec. The result? It was sharp, tart, slightly sweet—and it tasted like a childhood rerun in cocktail form.
Cherry Margarita
Equipment
- Blender or Shaker
- Margarita Glasses
Ingredients
Main
- 1.5 cups frozen or fresh cherries pitted
- 2 oz blanco tequila
- 1 oz lime juice freshly squeezed
- 0.75 oz triple sec
- 0.5 oz agave syrup adjust to taste
- 1 cup ice
Instructions
- Add all ingredients to a blender and blend until smooth. Adjust sweetness to taste.
- Pour into chilled, sugar-rimmed margarita glasses and garnish with lime and cherries.
Notes
Since then, cherry margaritas have become my way of bottling sunshine, turning Tuesday dinners into something festive, and answering friends’ texts that read “bring something fruity.” It’s a drink with personality: bold, bright, and never boring.
Cherry Margarita Basics You’ll Love
Let’s break it down. A cherry margarita is a colorful, flavor-packed version of the classic cocktail, blending tequila, cherry juice or muddled cherries, lime juice, and an orange liqueur like triple sec. It’s ruby-hued, tart-sweet, and totally crushable.
You can start with a traditional cherry margarita recipe, or experiment with frozen fruit for a slushy twist. Want to branch out? The blackberry lemonade margarita offers a similarly bold berry spin.
Whether you shake it up for taco night or freeze it into popsicles for a backyard bash, the cherry margarita delivers refreshment and flair. And yes—Grandma Rosa still makes me show her every first sip over video call. If it doesn’t sing, we tweak until it does.
Building the Perfect Cherry Margarita
Essential Ingredients (Fresh or Frozen)
The beauty of a cherry margarita lies in its balance—bright citrus, sweet fruit, bold tequila. To get that just-right harmony, start with quality ingredients. Here’s what you’ll need for the classic version:
- Tequila: Go for blanco (silver) for a clean, agave-forward flavor that doesn’t overshadow the cherry.
- Cherries: Fresh pitted cherries (Bing or Rainier) are ideal, but frozen cherries work just as well—especially if you’re blending a frozen version.
- Lime Juice: Always fresh. Bottled won’t cut it here.
- Triple Sec: Or use another orange liqueur like Cointreau or Grand Marnier.
- Sweetener: A little agave syrup or cherry syrup can balance tart limes or sour cherries.
If you’re using fresh cherries, muddle them in your shaker with the lime juice before adding tequila and triple sec. For a smoother drink, blend all ingredients and strain.
One reason I keep cherries in the freezer is for impromptu happy hours. Frozen fruit also adds body to the cocktail without watering it down like ice does. You can even toss in a few frozen raspberries or blueberries if you’re craving a mix—think of it as a sister to the blackberry lemonade margarita.
Choosing the Right Tequila and Cherries
Not all tequilas are created equal. Blanco tequila keeps things light and citrusy—perfect for showcasing cherry flavor. If you want something deeper, a smooth reposado brings out more oak and spice, which pairs beautifully with darker cherry varieties.
As for cherries, I stick to sweet-tart Bing for everyday sipping. Rainier cherries lend a softer, golden sweetness if you want to change things up. For something with a little more edge, you can take inspiration from the bold citrus punch of the blood orange screaming margarita and add a splash of blood orange juice—it complements cherries like a dream.
Customizations & Frozen Versions
How to Make a Frozen Cherry Margarita at Home
When it’s blazing hot and you want something cool, frozen cherry margaritas hit all the right notes. They’re smooth, tangy, and icy enough to make you forget about the temperature outside.
To make one at home, blend:
- 1½ cups of frozen cherries
- 2 oz blanco tequila
- 1 oz fresh lime juice
- ¾ oz triple sec or orange juice
- ½ oz agave syrup (adjust to taste)
- 1–1½ cups of ice (depending on texture preference)
Blend until silky, then pour into a chilled margarita or rocks glass. Want to switch things up? Toss in a few chunks of frozen pineapple. It adds creaminess and plays beautifully with the cherry’s tart edge. The method used in the frozen pineapple margarita guide works like magic for cherry blends too.
If you’re after a drink with extra depth, try blending in a touch of coconut water or even a splash of soda water after blending—just enough for a sparkling lift.
Can You Make It Without Triple Sec? Absolutely
No triple sec? No problem. You can still create a cherry margarita that sings. Replace triple sec with fresh orange juice or a few dashes of orange bitters. This keeps the citrus complexity without the added alcohol.
You can also skip it entirely and rely on lime juice, cherry syrup, and a high-quality tequila. The trick is tasting as you go. Start with equal parts lime and cherry, then adjust the sweetness and balance from there.
If you’re watching calories or sugar, the skinny margarita recipe gives you a solid low-sugar structure that works beautifully with cherry add-ins. Just swap the citrus base for cherry and lime.
These custom options prove one thing: the cherry margarita is more versatile than most people think. Frozen or shaken, sweetened or stripped-down, there’s room to make it yours.
Serving & Pairing
How to Serve It So It Sings
Once your cherry margarita is ready, don’t just pour and go—presentation matters. Start with a chilled margarita or rocks glass. For an extra burst of flavor, rim the glass with lime and dip it in sugar, coarse salt, or even Tajín for a tangy kick. That little detail can completely change the first sip.
Pour the margarita over fresh ice if you’ve shaken it, or straight into the glass from the blender if it’s frozen. Garnish with a fresh lime wheel or a skewer of cherries—fresh or brandied both work great. A little mint adds color and aroma if you’re feeling extra.
Hosting a gathering? Batch it ahead. Multiply the ingredients by the number of guests, mix everything (except ice) in a pitcher, and chill. Right before serving, shake or blend each portion to order. It’s a crowd-pleaser and a conversation starter.
Variations to Try Next
One of the best things about cherry margaritas is how easily they evolve. If you like a bit of heat, muddle in a few jalapeño slices—it creates a spicy cherry margarita that’s both bold and balanced. For a more tropical flair, add pineapple juice or coconut water. You’ll get the vibes of a delightful Malibu pineapple margarita, with the cherry cutting through that island sweetness.
Craving something more decadent? A splash of amaretto adds almond warmth that deepens the cherry flavor—great for evening sipping. Or go wild and make cherry margarita popsicles. Freeze the mix in molds and serve with a lime wedge. They’re perfect for barbecues, brunches, or even bridal showers.
Cherry margaritas aren’t a one-trick cocktail. With a few clever swaps and additions, they transform into tropical blends, spicy refreshers, or frozen treats. Keep experimenting—and let flavor guide the way.
Conclusion
Cherry margaritas aren’t just another fruit twist—they’re a cocktail with soul. Whether you love yours shaken, frozen, or with a spicy edge, there’s a version that speaks your flavor language. I created mine during a nostalgic kitchen moment, but every sip since has been shared at summer parties, lazy Sundays, and impromptu friend nights.
Let this recipe be your base, but don’t stop there. Try the blackberry lemonade margarita next or go tropical with the delightful Malibu pineapple margarita.
For more delicious recipes like these follow us on Facebook and Pinterest.
What is a Cherry Margarita made of?
A classic cherry margarita includes tequila, lime juice, triple sec (or orange liqueur), and either cherry juice or muddled cherries. Sweeteners like agave or cherry syrup may be added to taste.
Can I make a Cherry Margarita without triple sec?
Yes! You can replace triple sec with orange juice, orange bitters, or skip it entirely. Adjust cherry and lime balance, and add a touch of agave syrup for sweetness.
What alcohol goes best with cherry in a margarita?
Blanco tequila is the go-to, offering a clean agave base. Reposado brings a smoky depth. Amaretto or orange liqueurs also enhance cherry’s bold flavor.
How do you make a frozen Cherry Margarita at home?
Blend frozen cherries, lime juice, tequila, and sweetener with ice until smooth. Optional: add pineapple or coconut water for a tropical variation.